236128 – [ Mac wk1 ] 8X imported/w3c/web-platform-tests/pointerevents/pointerevent (layout-tests) are flaky text failures

NEW 236128

[ Mac wk1 ] 8X imported/w3c/web-platform-tests/pointerevents/pointerevent (layout-tests) are flaky text failures

https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=236128

Summary [ Mac wk1 ] 8X imported/w3c/web-platform-tests/pointerevents/pointerevent (la...

Robert Jenner

Reported 2022-02-03 22:31:40 PST

Attachments
Test list generated and used for failure reproduction. (291.10 KB, text/plain) 2022-02-25 13:56 PST, Robert Jenner	no flags	Details
View All Add attachment proposed patch, testcase, etc.

Radar WebKit Bug Importer

Comment 1 2022-02-03 22:32:11 PST

<rdar://problem/88474722>

Robert Jenner

Comment 2 2022-02-25 13:16:03 PST

I found one additional test that also goes with these too: imported/w3c/web-platform-tests/pointerevents/pointerevent_pointercapture-in-shadow-dom.html HISTORY: https://results.webkit.org/?suite=layout-tests&test=imported%2Fw3c%2Fweb-platform-tests%2Fpointerevents%2Fpointerevent_pointercapture-in-shadow-dom.html

Robert Jenner

Comment 3 2022-02-25 13:47:56 PST

Robert Jenner

Comment 4 2022-02-25 13:50:31 PST

TEXT DIFF FOR "imported/w3c/web-platform-tests/pointerevents/pointerevent_mouse_capture_change_hover.html": PASS Mouse down and capture to green. -PASS Mouse down at green and capture to blue. -PASS Mouse down and capture to green, move to blue and release capture +FAIL Mouse down at green and capture to blue. assert_array_equals: Received events: green received pointermove,green received pointermove,green received pointermove,green received pointermove lengths differ, expected array ["green received pointerover", "green received pointerenter", "green received pointermove", "green received pointerdown", "green received pointerout", "green received pointerleave", "blue received pointerover", "blue received pointerenter", "blue received gotpointercapture", "blue received pointermove", "blue received pointermove"] length 11, got ["green received pointermove", "green received pointermove", "green received pointermove", "green received pointermove"] length 4 +FAIL Mouse down and capture to green, move to blue and release capture assert_array_equals: Received events: green received pointermove,green received lostpointercapture,green received pointerout,green received pointerleave,green received pointerover,green received pointerenter,green received pointermove,green received pointerout,green received pointerleave,blue received pointerover,blue received pointerenter,blue received pointermove,blue received pointermove lengths differ, expected array ["green received pointerover", "green received pointerenter", "green received pointermove", "green received pointerdown", "green received gotpointercapture", "green received pointermove", "green received lostpointercapture", "green received pointerout", "green received pointerleave", "blue received pointerover", "blue received pointerenter", "blue received pointermove"] length 12, got ["green received pointermove", "green received lostpointercapture", "green received pointerout", "green received pointerleave", "green received pointerover", "green received pointerenter", "green received pointermove", "green received pointerout", "green received pointerleave", "blue received pointerover", "blue received pointerenter", "blue received pointermove", "blue received pointermove"] length 13 DIFF URL: https://build.webkit.org/results/Apple-BigSur-Release-WK1-Tests/r290514%20(8626)/imported/w3c/web-platform-tests/pointerevents/pointerevent_mouse_capture_change_hover-pretty-diff.html

Robert Jenner

Comment 5 2022-02-25 13:51:29 PST

TEXT DIFF FOR "imported/w3c/web-platform-tests/pointerevents/pointerevent_mouse_pointercapture_in_frame.html": -FAIL Test pointer capture event route across the same-origin frame: Mouse down at inner frame and set pointer capture. assert_array_equals: Received events: innerFrame received pointermove,innerFrame received pointerdown,innerFrame received gotpointercapture,innerFrame received pointermove,innerFrame received pointermove,innerFrame received pointerup,innerFrame received lostpointercapture,outerFrame received pointermove lengths differ, expected array ["innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointerdown", "innerFrame received gotpointercapture", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointerup", "innerFrame received lostpointercapture"] length 7, got ["innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointerdown", "innerFrame received gotpointercapture", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointerup", "innerFrame received lostpointercapture", "outerFrame received pointermove"] length 8 -FAIL Test pointer capture event route across the same-origin frame: Mouse down at outer frame body and set pointer capture. assert_array_equals: Received events: outerFrame received pointermove,outerFrame received pointerdown,outerFrame received gotpointercapture,outerFrame received pointermove,outerFrame received pointerup,outerFrame received lostpointercapture,innerFrame received pointermove lengths differ, expected array ["outerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointerdown", "outerFrame received gotpointercapture", "outerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointerup", "outerFrame received lostpointercapture"] length 6, got ["outerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointerdown", "outerFrame received gotpointercapture", "outerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointerup", "outerFrame received lostpointercapture", "innerFrame received pointermove"] length 7 -FAIL Test pointer capture event route across the same-origin frame: Mouse down with set capture at inner frame, then release on next mouse move. assert_array_equals: Received events: innerFrame received pointermove,innerFrame received pointerdown,innerFrame received gotpointercapture,innerFrame received pointermove,innerFrame received lostpointercapture,innerFrameDocument received pointermove,outerFrame received pointerup,innerFrameDocument received pointermove,outerFrame received pointermove lengths differ, expected array ["innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointerdown", "innerFrame received gotpointercapture", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received lostpointercapture", "innerFrameDocument received pointermove", "innerFrameDocument received pointerup"] length 7, got ["innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointerdown", "innerFrame received gotpointercapture", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received lostpointercapture", "innerFrameDocument received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointerup", "innerFrameDocument received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointermove"] length 9 -FAIL Test pointercapture event route across the same-origin frame: Mouse down with set capture at outer frame, then release on next mouse move. assert_array_equals: Received events: outerFrame received pointermove,outerFrame received pointerdown,outerFrame received gotpointercapture,outerFrame received pointermove,outerFrame received lostpointercapture,innerFrameElement received pointermove,innerFrameElement received pointerup,innerFrame received pointermove lengths differ, expected array ["outerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointerdown", "outerFrame received gotpointercapture", "outerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received lostpointercapture", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointerup"] length 7, got ["outerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointerdown", "outerFrame received gotpointercapture", "outerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received lostpointercapture", "innerFrameElement received pointermove", "innerFrameElement received pointerup", "innerFrame received pointermove"] length 8 +FAIL Test pointer capture event route across the same-origin frame: Mouse down at inner frame and set pointer capture. assert_array_equals: Received events: innerFrame received pointermove,innerFrame received pointerdown,innerFrame received gotpointercapture,innerFrame received pointermove,innerFrame received pointermove,innerFrame received pointermove,innerFrame received pointermove,outerFrame received pointermove lengths differ, expected array ["innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointerdown", "innerFrame received gotpointercapture", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointerup", "innerFrame received lostpointercapture"] length 7, got ["innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointerdown", "innerFrame received gotpointercapture", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointermove"] length 8 +FAIL Test pointer capture event route across the same-origin frame: Mouse down at outer frame body and set pointer capture. assert_array_equals: Received events: outerFrame received pointermove,outerFrame received pointermove,innerFrameElement received pointermove,innerFrameElement received pointermove,innerFrame received pointermove lengths differ, expected array ["outerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointerdown", "outerFrame received gotpointercapture", "outerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointerup", "outerFrame received lostpointercapture"] length 6, got ["outerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrameElement received pointermove", "innerFrameElement received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointermove"] length 5 +FAIL Test pointer capture event route across the same-origin frame: Mouse down with set capture at inner frame, then release on next mouse move. assert_array_equals: Received events: innerFrame received pointermove,innerFrame received lostpointercapture,innerFrame received pointermove,innerFrame received pointermove,innerFrameDocument received pointermove,outerFrame received pointermove,innerFrameDocument received pointermove,outerFrame received pointermove lengths differ, expected array ["innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointerdown", "innerFrame received gotpointercapture", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received lostpointercapture", "innerFrameDocument received pointermove", "innerFrameDocument received pointerup"] length 7, got ["innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received lostpointercapture", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrameDocument received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrameDocument received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointermove"] length 8 +FAIL Test pointercapture event route across the same-origin frame: Mouse down with set capture at outer frame, then release on next mouse move. assert_array_equals: Received events: outerFrame received pointermove,outerFrame received pointermove,innerFrameElement received pointermove,innerFrameElement received pointermove,innerFrameElement received pointermove,innerFrame received pointermove lengths differ, expected array ["outerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointerdown", "outerFrame received gotpointercapture", "outerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received lostpointercapture", "innerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointerup"] length 7, got ["outerFrame received pointermove", "outerFrame received pointermove", "innerFrameElement received pointermove", "innerFrameElement received pointermove", "innerFrameElement received pointermove", "innerFrame received pointermove"] length 6 DIFF URL: https://build.webkit.org/results/Apple-BigSur-Release-WK1-Tests/r290514%20(8626)/imported/w3c/web-platform-tests/pointerevents/pointerevent_mouse_pointercapture_in_frame-pretty-diff.html

Robert Jenner

Comment 6 2022-02-25 13:55:16 PST

I was not able to reproduce any of the failures by running the tests standalone. However, I was able to reproduce the failures by generating a test list. All of these tests ran on the same worker, so when I ran as a test list I got all of the tests to fail using the following: run-webkit-tests --test-list <location of test list> --child-process=1 --force -1 I have attached the test list to this bug, and will work on figuring out what causes these tests to fail.

Robert Jenner

Comment 7 2022-02-25 13:56:15 PST

Created attachment 453256 [details] Test list generated and used for failure reproduction.

Robert Jenner

Comment 8 2022-03-14 18:59:08 PDT

After playing with the reproduction using the attached test list, I believe that the following test: imported/w3c/web-platform-tests/html/user-activation/activation-trigger-mouse-right.html Is what is causing the others to fail. I have skipped that test on Mac wk1 here to prove if the theory is correct, and matches what I was reproducing locally: https://commits.webkit.org/248414@main

Ryan Haddad

Comment 9 2022-05-18 15:12:30 PDT

*** Bug 236126 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

Jer Noble

Comment 10 2023-06-29 23:03:01 PDT

This test requires that we fire the "auxclick" event, which we don't support.

Note You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.

Status NEW

Resolution

Priority P2

Severity Normal

Classification Unclassified

Version WebKit Nightly Build

Hardware Unspecified

OS Unspecified

Product WebKit

Component New Bugs

Assignee

Nobody

Reported

2022-02-03 22:31 PST

Modified

2023-06-30 07:56 PDT History

CC List

4 users Show

URL

Keywords InRadar

Duplicates (1)

236126 View as bug list

Depends on

Blocks