Bug 265465 – REGRESSION(267236@main): SVG may incorrectly be clipped when an SVGFilter is applied to its root

• Status: RESOLVED
• Resolution: FIXED
• Component: SVG

[Bastian Kröger]

Created attachment 468786 [details]
Left wrong, right correct.

browse:
 
https://editor.printess.com/printess-editor/buyer-test.html?name=engraving-one-image&version=draft&token=eyJhbGciOiJSUzI1NiIsImtpZCI6InByaW50ZXNzLXNhYXMtYWxwaGEiLCJ0eXAiOiJKV1QifQ.eyJzdWIiOiJneTh6NDRFbUxpWjB2clVLclhsV3RpWlkxNUQyIiwianRpIjoibnl4NGJFZlZ5SVVvM1NkR2dYVnEtempzS3hlb0FYZUYiLCJyb2xlIjoic2hvcCIsIm5iZiI6MTYxODg2ODUxMSwiZXhwIjoxOTM0MjI4NTExLCJpYXQiOjE2MTg4Njg1MTEsImlzcyI6IlByaW50ZXNzIEdtYkggJiBDby5LRyIsImF1ZCI6InByaW50ZXNzLXNhYXMifQ.CuI6zdCzBm2y3t2GBD4pYdyztFzSeSEfdGIDBeiZIYvzQckB9oEB1Z4hDkBCGZGBtTMRyuHCbkwZgO6uxD-ZyahifiqrIqfqSqtFEGwgZUF87TvV_KlrYWBzDNTaUIQjr-yUoxLkdnEMzh-3D5qV8UKWIDfqwnYd0KhJiB2K9CSg82_etnz5Lk-altMDAT8b1AnzxcjRAJ9_b6-CAJFXG6AAnfdl7c_PS3sD-RPOkJ75Ta2glfikIiGZzfh09bn5Ptk7rucRdxUsLCLR6m5nUFpZbV77d2eqRw8pT4Kl-5by5gvMr1wUBGbEx751CNXtcCO3qk4uNnptfZ3yCpK0Z2FOo2CYLZBzmDiYCrdFV5U-_SZuVOEl8vk0uR3tj_PQci_R7MlQOjpB4NjlKckQ2zGvBSKNeupuiC71UZ2AT5BFlbqMsuYu0necIztyKiWsBmbniVlLe-v7_paP1N4nS2haD2n4s4N_CenJqijtPggWsITfoLm2twCOe7yNB5IH7bcEFv1-MbANuaFmJVLOcTfc89Zi-mkidaHV-n_9qXypzyB-ih_27YBNluRGwcHgTEkbJecSssMfvHSt1MUuqX-8gbl7bhFGryqHA2gMoSZNDW0LkSYig2K3poOUumD67vtYdNSPLhOmDK4ck9wLAKLOvk6dtywg2qfV-58_VbI

See that only a grey part is rendered when using the svg filter.
In an old version the whole rectangle (if you click on it) was grey.
(You can also upload an image to see that only part of it is rendered)
When zooming in (via the slider on the right hand side), more of the image gets visible.

Tested on 17.1 (macOS and iOS), macOS 17.2 beta 3
When removing the filter, the whole image is rendered (without filter obviously).

Worked in 16.6 (macOS and iOS).

Tried everything I can imagine... But nothing works.

[Bastian Kröger]

Please use this url now:
https://editor.printess.com/v/2.3.0/printess-editor/buyer-test.html?name=engraving-one-image&version=draft&token=eyJhbGciOiJSUzI1NiIsImtpZCI6InByaW50ZXNzLXNhYXMtYWxwaGEiLCJ0eXAiOiJKV1QifQ.eyJzdWIiOiJneTh6NDRFbUxpWjB2clVLclhsV3RpWlkxNUQyIiwianRpIjoibnl4NGJFZlZ5SVVvM1NkR2dYVnEtempzS3hlb0FYZUYiLCJyb2xlIjoic2hvcCIsIm5iZiI6MTYxODg2ODUxMSwiZXhwIjoxOTM0MjI4NTExLCJpYXQiOjE2MTg4Njg1MTEsImlzcyI6IlByaW50ZXNzIEdtYkggJiBDby5LRyIsImF1ZCI6InByaW50ZXNzLXNhYXMifQ.CuI6zdCzBm2y3t2GBD4pYdyztFzSeSEfdGIDBeiZIYvzQckB9oEB1Z4hDkBCGZGBtTMRyuHCbkwZgO6uxD-ZyahifiqrIqfqSqtFEGwgZUF87TvV_KlrYWBzDNTaUIQjr-yUoxLkdnEMzh-3D5qV8UKWIDfqwnYd0KhJiB2K9CSg82_etnz5Lk-altMDAT8b1AnzxcjRAJ9_b6-CAJFXG6AAnfdl7c_PS3sD-RPOkJ75Ta2glfikIiGZzfh09bn5Ptk7rucRdxUsLCLR6m5nUFpZbV77d2eqRw8pT4Kl-5by5gvMr1wUBGbEx751CNXtcCO3qk4uNnptfZ3yCpK0Z2FOo2CYLZBzmDiYCrdFV5U-_SZuVOEl8vk0uR3tj_PQci_R7MlQOjpB4NjlKckQ2zGvBSKNeupuiC71UZ2AT5BFlbqMsuYu0necIztyKiWsBmbniVlLe-v7_paP1N4nS2haD2n4s4N_CenJqijtPggWsITfoLm2twCOe7yNB5IH7bcEFv1-MbANuaFmJVLOcTfc89Zi-mkidaHV-n_9qXypzyB-ih_27YBNluRGwcHgTEkbJecSssMfvHSt1MUuqX-8gbl7bhFGryqHA2gMoSZNDW0LkSYig2K3poOUumD67vtYdNSPLhOmDK4ck9wLAKLOvk6dtywg2qfV-58_VbI

(added version, so the error is still visible)

I could fix the issue by now by moving the filter: url(#blah) part to the image in the svg itself.
The filter was defined inside of the svg, maybe that was the problem and changed since 16.6.

Kind regards,
Bastian

[Radar WebKit Bug Importer]

<rdar://problem/118938065>

[Said Abou-Hallawa]

This is a regression of 267236@main

[Bastian Kröger]

I tested on Version 17.2 (19617.1.16.11.2) and this does not fix the bug reported.
From the changelog the regression bug linked should be fixed in there.
But it does not fix this issue here.
What am I missing here? :)

Kind regards,
Bastian

[Said Abou-Hallawa]

Pull request: https://github.com/WebKit/WebKit/pull/25512

[Said Abou-Hallawa]

*** Bug 270567 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

[EWS]

Committed 277325@main (cb5290644a69): <https://commits.webkit.org/277325@main>

Reviewed commits have been landed. Closing PR #25512 and removing active labels.