Bug 20655 – Layout tests need a way to disable smart insert or delete

• Status: RESOLVED
• Resolution: FIXED
• Component: Tools / Tests

[Glenn Wilson]

Currently, smartInsertOrDelete is always on by default (it is set to true when the WebView is created), and there is no way for a layout test to set it to false.  

Ideally, layout tests would be able to toggle this flag to test features that are smartInsertOrDelete sensitive.

[Glenn Wilson]

Created attachment 23232 [details]
Possible fix to bug 20655

Here is a possible fix to this issue.

This patch adds a new method to LayoutTestController, "setSmartInsertDeleteEnabled(bool)", which allows the test to set or unset this behavior in the webView.  Also added a test that illustrates that when smart editing is disabled, smart deleting behavior changes -- in fact, the test is just one of the smart delete tests modified to have this setting disabled.

As far as I can tell, disabling smart editing in one test does not affect others.  Tests before and after this test that require smart editing still pass on my system.

However, I am only able to test this on a Windows system, so many of the Mac-only layout tests don't run for me regardless.  Is there a way for me to try this patch on a publicly available Mac builder, or is there a way that a reviewer help me with this?

[Sam Weinig]

Comment on attachment 23232 [details]
Possible fix to bug 20655

This will break the mac build as you have not included a version of LayoutTestController::setSmartInsertDeleteEnabled for the mac.

[Glenn Wilson]

Created attachment 23308 [details]
Possible fix to bug 20655

Here is an improved patch that also modifies the mac/LayoutTestController.

Should this also modify the Gtk / Qt versions of LayoutTestController as well?

[Glenn Wilson]

Comment on attachment 23308 [details]
Possible fix to bug 20655

oops, found a bug in this...

[Glenn Wilson]

Created attachment 23310 [details]
Possible fix w/ mac support

This should also modify LayoutTestControllerMac.mm...sorry about that.

[Mark Rowe (bdash)]

Do we need to reset the state of smart insert/delete between tests?

[Glenn Wilson]

Comment on attachment 23310 [details]
Possible fix w/ mac support

From just a quick test, yes, it does look like it needs to be reset.  Working on an improved patch now...

[Glenn Wilson]

Created attachment 23362 [details]
Possible fix to bug 20655

Here is the fix with a modified DumpRenderTree that resets the smartInsertDeleteEnabled flag to true after each test.  I tested this by adding a test that required smart delete that would run last, after the tests that disabled smartInsertDelete.   I didn't include this "teardown" test in the patch, though, since it is merely one of the existing smart deleting tests.

[Adam Barth]

Will land.

[Adam Barth]

My Mac Mini died in the middle of testing this patch.  I'm going to take it into the store tomorrow.

[Adam Barth]

It's going to be a week before I get my Mac Mini back.  Unassigning.

[Darin Adler]

I'll land this.

[Darin Adler]

http://trac.webkit.org/changeset/37633