Bug 3330 – REGRESSION (125-300): JavaScript "children" array includes all descendants, not just immediate children

• Status: VERIFIED
• Resolution: FIXED
• Component: DOM

[Timothy Hatcher]

Radar: 4063841

Summary:
The "children" array on nodes returns children's children in on flattened array. This is a regression from 
Safari 1.2 and from the DOM specs.

A test case is setup here. It "children.length" should return 5 for the number of div elements.

http://colloquy.info/test/children.html

Steps to Reproduce:
1) Access the children array on a DOM node with JavaScript.

Expected Results:
Only immediate children should be in the array, not the children's children, etc.

Actual Results:
The array has more elements than expected if the immediate children have children elements also. They 
all get flattened out into the main array (a recursive behavior).

Regression:
This is a regression from Safari 1.2 builds.

Notes:
Test case at: http://colloquy.info/test/children.html

[Dave Hyatt]

This is actually a bug with collections in general.  traverseNextItem begins by calling traverseNextNode, 
but traverseNextNode is a deep traversal.  This means that shallow traversals like children are deep when 
they should not be when you make repeated calls to traverseNextItem to iterate (as calcLength does).  

The same is true of some of the other collections that should not be deep, and so this bug could be the 
cause of other HTML collection DOM bugs.

[Timothy Hatcher]

Created attachment 2168 [details]
Fix

[Maciej Stachowiak]

I sent review comment to Timothy by email.

[Timothy Hatcher]

This was fixed with the attached patch, and landed by Maciej. Thought I would close this and help out.