Bug 15118 – WebKit Gdk fails to build due to icu, under some conditions

• Status: RESOLVED
• Resolution: WORKSFORME
• Component: WebKit Misc.

[Mike Hommey]

(it would be a good thing to have a WebKit Gdk component)

Latest icu release (3.8) now includes a --enable-weak-threads flag to configure, which makes icu not link against the pthread library. Let's not discuss why it's good or bad. What is important is that it means icu-config doesn't report -lpthread in the ldflags, which it shouldn't have been in the first place, since you don't need to link against the pthread library to *use* icu.

Anyways, the WebKit Gdk build shouldn't rely on icu-config providing the -lpthread necessary to it, it should define it itself.

A trivial fix is to add -lpthread to LIBS for gdk-port in JavaScriptCore/kjs/testkjs.pro and WebKit.pri. But I don't know if that would be okay for something else than Linux...

[Mike Hommey]

Created attachment 16275 [details]
Proposed patch

[Adam Roben (:aroben)]

Comment on attachment 16275 [details]
Proposed patch

The changes and ChangeLogs look sane to me, but I'll leave it to some of the Qt/Gtk guys to review this.

[Holger Freyther]

AFAIK FreeBSD has at least two different threading implementations. Hardcoding -lpthread is something we should not do.

So if ICU is not using POSIX thread symbols, who is using them? The one who has the dependency on pthread should introduce that with --ldflags. So an actual link error would be nice to see what we are talking about.

[Mike Hommey]

(In reply to comment #3)
> AFAIK FreeBSD has at least two different threading implementations. Hardcoding
> -lpthread is something we should not do.
> 
> So if ICU is not using POSIX thread symbols, who is using them? The one who has
> the dependency on pthread should introduce that with --ldflags. So an actual
> link error would be nice to see what we are talking about.

Erm, WebKit does require it in several places, just grep pthread in the code.

[Mike Hommey]

Mmmmmm there might have been something else than the missing -lpthread... The original error message was as below, but it actually doesn't occur anymore here. I suspect a combination of missing -lpthread from icu and some glibc fuckage.
Let's mark this bug worksforme... I'll reopen if I can reproduce again.

> g++ -Wl,--as-needed -o ../testkjs testkjs.o pcre_get.o pcre_refcount.o pcre_ucp_findchar.o pcre_compile.o pcre_globals.o pcre_config.o pcre_version.o pcre_info.o pcre_study.o pcre_exec.o pcre_xclass.o pcre_tables.o pcre_maketables.o pcre_try_flipped.o pcre_ord2utf8.o pcre_fullinfo.o TCSystemAlloc.o Assertions.o HashTable.o FastMalloc.o NP_jsobject.o npruntime.o runtime_array.o runtime.o runtime_method.o runtime_object.o runtime_root.o c_class.o c_instance.o c_runtime.o c_utility.o DateMath.o JSWrapperObject.o PropertyNameArray.o array_object.o bool_object.o collector.o CommonIdentifiers.o Context.o date_object.o debugger.o dtoa.o error_object.o ExecState.o fpconst.o function.o function_object.o identifier.o internal.o interpreter.o JSImmediate.o JSLock.o lexer.o list.o lookup.o math_object.o nodes.o nodes2string.o number_object.o object.o object_object.o operations.o Parser.o property_map.o property_slot.o regexp.o regexp_object.o scope_chain.o string_object.o ustring.o value.o grammar.o     -lm -L/usr/lib -licui18n -licuuc -licudata -lm
> collector.o: In function `currentThreadStackBase':
> /tmp/webkit-0~svn25144/build-gdk/JavaScriptCore/kjs/../../../JavaScriptCore/kjs/collector.cpp:290: undefined reference to `pthread_getattr_np'
> /tmp/webkit-0~svn25144/build-gdk/JavaScriptCore/kjs/../../../JavaScriptCore/kjs/collector.cpp:292: undefined reference to `pthread_attr_getstack'
> /tmp/webkit-0~svn25144/build-gdk/JavaScriptCore/kjs/../../../JavaScriptCore/kjs/collector.cpp:290: undefined reference to `pthread_getattr_np'
> /tmp/webkit-0~svn25144/build-gdk/JavaScriptCore/kjs/../../../JavaScriptCore/kjs/collector.cpp:292: undefined reference to `pthread_attr_getstack'
> collect2: ld returned 1 exit status
> make[2]: *** [../testkjs] Error 1
> make[2]: Leaving directory `/tmp/webkit-0~svn25144/build-gdk/JavaScriptCore/kjs'
> make[1]: *** [sub-JavaScriptCore-kjs-testkjs-pro-make_default-ordered] Error 2
> make[1]: Leaving directory `/tmp/webkit-0~svn25144/build-gdk'
> make: *** [build-gdk-stamp] Error 2

[Holger Freyther]

Okay, if it reoccurs I would probably propose to add gthread-2.0 to the PKG_CONFIG list.