Bug 9435 – [S60] Can't build the s60WebKit for gcce target

• Component: Tools / Tests
• Status: CLOSED INVALID

[Sébastien Dalis]

I've downloaded the latest version of the S60Webkit project and successfully build  it for the WINSCW target. ("build.bat -w"). I can't compile for the gcce target ("build.bat -g"). 
I've checked my dev. environement :
- latest Symbian SDK 3rd edition
- perl v5.6.1

Does anyone succeed to compile for this target ?

Regards.
S. Dalis

[David Carson]

Can you provide more detais about where it is failing, such as a copy of the command line output when it fails.

Thanks

[Sébastien Dalis]

Hi,

The first compilation gives an error regarding the symbol definition of the "WebCore_gcceU.DEF" file. An error was raised : "; #<TI># symbol not defined". 
The "WebCore_gcceU.DEF" file contained the following :
	_ZTI14CWebCoreBridge @ 147 NONAME ; #<TI>#
	_ZTI16CWebCoreSettings @ 148 NONAME ; #<TI>#
	_ZTI20CWebCorePageDataItem @ 149 NONAME ; #<TI>#
	_ZTI23CWebCoreGraphicsContext @ 150 NONAME ; #<TI>#
	_ZTV14CWebCoreBridge @ 151 NONAME ; #<VT>#
	_ZTV16CWebCoreSettings @ 152 NONAME ; #<VT>#
	_ZTV20CWebCorePageDataItem @ 153 NONAME ; #<VT>#
	_ZTV23CWebCoreGraphicsContext @ 154 NONAME ; #<VT>#
so I removed it.

Then the compilation failed with the following:

It seems that the library "HistoryProvider.dso" is missing. I've checked into the file "s60\S60Internals\S60LibsGcce.zip" where all the needed library are, and the library is not there.
The compilation gives the following:

F:\Symbian\9.1\S60_3rd\s60>build -gt
Building under x: drive

7 archives were successfully processed.
Synching \s60\LayoutTests with \epoc32\winscw\c\LayoutTests
0 LayoutTests files updated
0 LayoutTests files removed
  make -r  -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\GCCE.make" TARGET CFG=UREL VERBOSE=-s
arm-none-symbianelf-ld: ..\EPOC32\RELEASE\ARMV5\LIB\HistoryProvider.dso: No such file: No such file or directory
make[1]: *** [..\EPOC32\RELEASE\GCCE\UREL\browserengine.dll] Error 1
make: *** [TARGETWEBKIT] Error 2
make -s  -r -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\MEMMAN\GCCE\MEMMAN.GCCE" UREL
make -s  -r -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\PCRE\GCCE\PCRE.GCCE" UREL
make -s  -r -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\JAVASCRIPTCORE\GCCE\JAVASCRIPTCORE.GCCE" UREL
make -s  -r -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\KHTML\GCCE\KHTML.GCCE" UREL
make -s  -r -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\KWQ\GCCE\KWQ.GCCE" UREL
make -s  -r -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\WEBCORE\GCCE\WEBCORE.GCCE" UREL
make -s  -C \s60\WEBKIT\group -f "ICONS.MK" TO_ROOT=..\..\.. EPOCBLD=..\..\..\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\ICONS\GCCE TO_BLDINF=..\..\..\s60 PLATFORM=GCCE CFG=UREL BLD
make -s  -r -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\RESLOADER\GCCE\RESLOADER.GCCE" UREL
make -s  -r -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\BROWSERCORE\GCCE\BROWSERCORE.GCCE" UREL
make -s  -r -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\BROWSERVIEW\GCCE\BROWSERVIEW.GCCE" UREL
make -s  -r -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\PLUGIN\GCCE\PLUGIN.GCCE" UREL
make -s  -r -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\BROWSERREC\GCCE\BROWSERREC.GCCE" UREL
make -s  -r -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\BROWSERCACHE\GCCE\BROWSERCACHE.GCCE" UREL
WARNING: Not attempting to create any import libraries.
When exports are frozen in "\s60\WEBKIT\EABI\BrowserCacheU.DEF", regenerate Makefile.
make -s  -r -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\WEBKIT\GCCE\WEBKIT.GCCE" UREL
Processing WebUi.pkg...
WebUi.pkg(24) : error: file I/O fault.
Sign WebUi.sis...
file I/O fault, cannot open WebUi.sis.
Delete intermediate files...
Impossible de trouver X:\s60\s60webui\webui\install\WebUi.sis
Done, please copy WebUi.sisx to your phone

        Completed in: 00:01:01

        Scanning build output for errors: 2 found

[Sébastien Dalis]

I've downloaded the last Symbian SDK (S60-SDK-0616-3.0-mr.3.749.zip on ) and tried to compile the s60WebKit on the GCCE target. There is no improvments.
Coud you provide me an update about his bug ?

Thank you.

[Bradley Morrison]

Can confirm GCCE compilations currently failing. As at r15189 I receive:

..\EPOC32\RELEASE\ARMV5\UREL\KWQ.lib(KWQKStandardDirs.o): In function `locate(char const*, QString const&, KInstance const*)':
Kwqkstandarddirs.cpp:(.text+0xa0): undefined reference to `Dll::FileName(TBuf<256>&)'
make[1]: *** [..\EPOC32\RELEASE\GCCE\UREL\WebCore.dll] Error 1

Some people may be looking at improving GCCE support shortly/now - I will request that they make some updates here. Can confirm ARMV5 hardware builds are still stable.

Please contact me for further information. Many thanks for your input!

[Bradley Morrison]

Can confirm. 

[Sébastien Dalis]

Created attachment 9585 [details]
script used to build the s60Webkit

[Sébastien Dalis]

Hi Bradley,

The compiler used is the ARM v2.2
I tried to compile for the ARMV5 target but this one is not an option of the script build.bat. I modified this one (please get the attached file) to add an option -a to compile for the ARMV5 target and the compilation fails with the following :

Creating \EPOC32\BUILD\S60\WEBUI\ARMV5\UREL
  make -r  -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\S60\ARMV5.make" TARGET CFG=UREL VERBOSE=-s
"\EPOC32\INCLUDE\RVCT2_2\RVCT2_2.h", line 21: Error:  #5: cannot open source input file "symbian_os_v9.1.hrh": No such file or directory
  #include <symbian_os_v9.1.hrh>
                                ^
make[1]: *** [..\EPOC32\BUILD\S60\MEMMAN\ARMV5\UREL\MemoryManager.o] Error 1
make: *** [TARGETMEMMAN] Error 2
make -s  -r -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\S60\MEMMAN\ARMV5\MEMMAN.ARMV5" UREL
Memorymanager.cpp
  make -r  -f "\EPOC32\BUILD\S60\ARMV5.make" FINAL CFG=UREL VERBOSE=-s
make -s  -C \S60\WEBKIT\group -f "ICONS.MK" TO_ROOT=..\..\.. EPOCBLD=..\..\..\EPOC32\BUILD\S60\ICONS\ARMV5 TO_BLDINF=..\..\..\S60 PLATFORM=ARMV5 CFG=UREL FINAL
make -s  -C \S60\S60WebUi\WebUi\group -f "WEBUIAIFSVGICONSDC.MK" TO_ROOT=..\..\..\.. EPOCBLD=..\..\..\..\EPOC32\BUILD\S60\WEBUIAIFSVGICONSDC\ARMV5 TO_BLDINF=..\.
.\..\..\S60 PLATFORM=ARMV5 CFG=UREL FINAL
make -s  -C \S60\S60WebUi\WebUi\group -f "WEBUIICONSDC.MK" TO_ROOT=..\..\..\.. EPOCBLD=..\..\..\..\EPOC32\BUILD\S60\WEBUIICONSDC\ARMV5 TO_BLDINF=..\..\..\..\S60
PLATFORM=ARMV5 CFG=UREL FINAL
Processing WebUiARM.pkg...
WebUiARM.pkg(24) : error: file I/O fault.
Sign WebUiARM.sis...
file I/O fault, cannot open WebUiARM.sis.
Delete intermediate files...
Impossible de trouver X:\s60\s60webui\webui\install\WebUiARM.sis
Done, please copy WebUiARM.sisx to your phone

        Completed in: 00:04:15

        Scanning build output for errors: 6 found

Do you know how to proceed to compile for this target ? Why isn't there an ARMV5 compilation option into the script build.bat ?

[Bradley Morrison]

(In reply to comment #7)
> Hi Bradley,

Hi Sebastien,

Apologies for the delay. We're really keen to get this compiling for hardware and the priority on this is going up RSN.

> I tried to compile for the ARMV5 target but this one is not an option of the
> script build.bat. 

Yeah, one of the things that build.bat does is sets up your environment to compile against the Carbide compilers. I can add in your ARMV5 support (thanks for that), but I'd probably feel better getting this working first.

> Do you know how to proceed to compile for this target ? 

As a quick workaround, copy symbian_os_v9.1.hrh from \epoc32\include\variant to \epoc32\include. When I do that it goes further but fails with 

Fast_malloc.cpp
Value.cpp
\s60\JavaScriptCore\group\EABI\JavaScriptCoreU.def(160) : DEFFILE ERROR: Incorrect EXPORTS statement syntax
make[1]: *** [..\EPOC32\BUILD\s60\JAVASCRIPTCORE\ARMV5\UREL\JavaScriptCore{000a0000}.exp] Error 255

Someone needs to look into this.

[Antoine Martin]

Hello,

Trying to compile for the ARMV5 target, we are missing the following libraries (the list may not be exhaustive):

XmlEngine.lib
HttpFilterCommon.lib
CenRepNotifHandler.lib
FeatMgr.lib
browserdialogsprovider.lib
ConnectionManager.lib
CookieManager.lib
WebUtils.lib
MultipartParser.lib 

These libs are provided for the winscw target under S60Internals\S60DynamicLibs.zip and S60Internals\S60StaticLibs.zip

Is there a way to get those for the ARMV5 target ?

[Bradley Morrison]

Created attachment 9879 [details]
Requested libs

[mathias]

Hi,
Thanks for the previous libs.
But two libraries are still missing for the ARMV5 target :
HistoryProvider.lib and SysLangUtil.lib

[mathias]

I have forgotten these one :
pagescaler.lib can not be found for ARMV5

Thanks, Mat.

[Bradley Morrison]

(In reply to comment #11)
> Hi,
> Thanks for the previous libs.
> But two libraries are still missing for the ARMV5 target :
> HistoryProvider.lib and SysLangUtil.lib

Hi,

Sorry, I'm travelling at the moment but will get back to you next week. In the meantime you may or may not be interested in mailing the webkit-dev mailing list or contacting our business development manager, [e-mail].

Thanks,
Bradley

[Shyam Sareen]

Hi

It is known problem that open source code sis file can't build with ARM5 at present. I will start working on this towards the end of next week ( around 8/25/06) and update the status when it is done.

[Bradley Morrison]

This bug has wandered onto compiling on ARMV5, so I'm forking it with bug 10469 which I raised specifically for the ARMV5 issue. Please leave this as the GCCE bug.

[Bradley Morrison]

Please see my recent email on the webkit dev mailing list.

[Bradley Morrison]

Updated some related libs in r16992. Still ongoing.

[Bradley Morrison]

Created attachment 11045 [details]
GCCE compilation fixes

[zalan]

Comment on attachment 11045 [details]
GCCE compilation fixes

r=me

[Bradley Morrison]

(In reply to comment #19)
> (From update of attachment 11045 [details] [edit])
> r=me
> 

Thanks - committed r17009.

[Bradley Morrison]

Created attachment 11075 [details]
Make reindeer installable

Patch to allow reindeer to install on a device.

[Bradley Morrison]

Created attachment 11078 [details]
updates to s60webui\install 

Last patch forgot to remove old package file.

[Bradley Morrison]

Created attachment 11079 [details]
correct patch this time ;)

Correct patch this time ;)

Please note now ChangeLog entry attached. I will add one when the review is past and I commit. Thanks

[zalan]

Comment on attachment 11079 [details]
correct patch this time ;)

r=me

[Bradley Morrison]

(In reply to comment #24)
> (From update of attachment 11079 [details] [edit])
> r=me
> 

Thanks - applied r17043.

[Bradley Morrison]

Created attachment 11113 [details]
Updated cannedimages.cpp & removed old rss & loc files

[Bradley Morrison]

r17707 updates RVCT support dlls (also used by GCCE):

11:02 < CIA-6> brmorris * r17077 /S60/trunk/S60Internals/ (ChangeLog
               target/RVCT/S60LibsRVCT.zip):
11:02 < CIA-6> 2006-10-13 brmorris <[e-mail]>
11:02 < CIA-6>  Reviewed by me.
11:02 < CIA-6>  DESC: Updated RVCT supporting libs.
11:02 < CIA-6>  http://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=9435
11:02 < CIA-6>  * target/RVCT/S60LibsRVCT.zip: Toolbar.dll & recentstore.dll

[Sachin Padma]

Comment on attachment 11113 [details]
Updated cannedimages.cpp & removed old rss & loc files

patch removed webkit_sdk.rss and webkit_sdk.loc files.

[Bradley Morrison]

Created attachment 11244 [details]
removes *gcce* not *sdk*

Previous patch removed *sdk* not *gcce*. This patch corrects that.

[Sachin Padma]

Comment on attachment 11244 [details]
removes *gcce* not *sdk*

r=me

[Bradley Morrison]

(In reply to comment #30)
> (From update of attachment 11244 [details] [edit])
> r=me
> 

Applied: r17380

[WyzoK]

This is what I did:
1. I followed all the instructions to install the sdk and webkit which are given on your website.
2. I tried to compile the .pkg to a .sis but I got a lot of missing files.
3. So I opened the .pkg and changed all the relative links to absolut ones, then made correctly the .sis 
4. Then I tried to install it on my nokia e50 (symbian, s60 3rd), but I got the error "Unable to install a protected application from an untrusted supplier".
5. I created a certificate following the instructions given by www.symbiansigned.com to obtain a Symbian Signed Developer Certificate.
6. After having signed the .sis, I tried again to install it. I got no problem with certification, but after choosing where I wanted to install it (mobilephone or memory card), I got the error "Required application access not granted". 
What suprised me is that normally I can use all capabilities because of my certification (which lets me use all capabilities for one IMEI serial). (and I seleted all the capabilities when created the .csr)

[Kari Pihkala]

I checked out the revision 18617 on 5 Jan 2007. Compiling for winscw works (build), but compilation for gcce fails (build -g). The gcce build used to work (e.g. r17211), but some new code has been added since, which causes errors.

Here's the errors from the build.log file.

JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h: At global scope:
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h:35: error: `int64_t' does not name a type
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h:35: error: `uint64_t' does not name a type
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h:52: error: `WTF::intHash' declared as an `inline' variable
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h:52: error: `unsigned int WTF::intHash' redeclared as different kind of symbol
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h:41: error: previous declaration of `unsigned int WTF::intHash(unsigned int)'
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h:52: error: declaration of `unsigned int WTF::intHash'
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h:41: error: conflicts with previous declaration `unsigned int WTF::intHash(unsigned int)'
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h:52: error: `uint64_t' was not declared in this scope
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h:53: error: expected `,' or `;' before '{' token
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h: In static member function `static unsigned int WTF::PtrHash<T>::hash(T)':
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h:73: error: `uintptr_t' undeclared (first use this function)
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h:73: error: (Each undeclared identifier is reported only once for each function it appears in.)
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h:73: error: template argument 1 is invalid
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h:73: error: `hash' is not a member of `<declaration error>'
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashFunctions.h:73: error: `uintptr_t' has not been declared
In file included from JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashTable.h:27,
                 from JavaScriptCore//bindings/hashmap.h:27,
                 from ..//EPOC32//include//oem/JavaScriptCore/runtime.h:31,
                 from ..//EPOC32//include//oem/JavaScriptCore/NP_jsobject.h:30,
                 from WEBCORE//kwq/KWQKHTMLPart.h:46,
                 from WEBCORE\\khtml\\rendering\\/render_text.h:35,
                 from WEBCORE\\khtml\\rendering\\Bidi.cpp:26:
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashTraits.h: At global scope:
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashTraits.h: In instantiation of `WTF::GenericHashTraitsBase< true, long long int>':
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashTraits.h:64:   instantiated from `WTF::GenericHashTraits<long long int>'
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashTraits.h:84:   instantiated from here
JavaScriptCore//bindings/HashTraits.h:53: error: no type named `SignedType' in `struct WTF::IntTypes<8u>'
WEBCORE\\khtml\\rendering\\Bidi.cpp: In member function `khtml::BidiIterator khtml::RenderBlock::findNextLineBreak(khtml::BidiIterator&, khtml::BidiState&)':
WEBCORE\\khtml\\rendering\\Bidi.cpp:1927: warning: comparison between signed and unsigned integer expressions
WEBCORE//kwq/KWQHashTable.h: In member function `KWQHashTable<K, V>::iterator KWQHashTable<K, V>::begin() [with K = QString, V = void*]':
WEBCORE//kwq/KWQDictImpl.h:66:   instantiated from here
WEBCORE//kwq/KWQHashTable.h:156: warning: comparison between signed and unsigned integer expressions
WEBCORE//kwq/KWQDictImpl.h:66:   instantiated from here
WEBCORE//kwq/KWQHashTable.h:157: warning: comparison between signed and unsigned integer expressions
WEBCORE//kwq/KWQHashTable.h: In member function `bool HashEntry<K, V>::valid() [with K = QString, V = void*]':
WEBCORE//kwq/KWQHashTable.h:70:   instantiated from `HashEntry<K, V>::operator bool() [with K = QString, V = void*]'
WEBCORE//kwq/KWQHashTable.h:156:   instantiated from `KWQHashTable<K, V>::iterator KWQHashTable<K, V>::begin() [with K = QString, V = void*]'
WEBCORE//kwq/KWQDictImpl.h:66:   instantiated from here
WEBCORE//kwq/KWQHashTable.h:65: warning: comparison between signed and unsigned integer expressions
make[1]: *** [..\EPOC32\BUILD\S60\KHTML\GCCE\UREL\bidi.o] Error 1
make: *** [LIBRARYKHTML] Error 2

[Bradley Morrison]

(In reply to comment #33)
> I checked out the revision 18617 on 5 Jan 2007. Compiling for winscw works
> (build), but compilation for gcce fails (build -g). The gcce build used to work
> (e.g. r17211), but some new code has been added since, which causes errors.

Yes, it appears that the scriptable plugins implementation has introduced regression in the GCCE build.

> Here's the errors from the build.log file.
 
Thanks Kari, this requirement will hopefully be escalated soon.

[Gurpreet]

(In reply to comment #34)
> (In reply to comment #33)
> > I checked out the revision 18617 on 5 Jan 2007. Compiling for winscw works
> > (build), but compilation for gcce fails (build -g). The gcce build used to work
> > (e.g. r17211), but some new code has been added since, which causes errors.
> 
> Yes, it appears that the scriptable plugins implementation has introduced
> regression in the GCCE build.
> 
> > Here's the errors from the build.log file.
> 
> Thanks Kari, this requirement will hopefully be escalated soon.
> 

Hi Bradley 

Any update on this....  I downloaded Revision 24352 yesterday, but still it's giving me errors when I compile for gcce.Errors are same as given in Comment 33.It's been long since this bug is open. Any tentative date when the fix will be released? Or if some body is having a workaround, pls post it here.

Br
Gurpreet
[e-mail]

[Bradley Morrison]

Bulk update of s60 bugs - tagging and closing.

[Bradley Morrison]

Bulk closing of all s60 platform bugs. 

Sorry for the noise!

[Joel Parks]

re-purposing InTSW keyword for use by QtWebkit team