Bug 46951

Summary:	Layout test failure for chromium fast/url/segments-from-data-url.html and fast/url/segments.html
Product:	WebKit	Reporter:	Hin-Chung Lam <hclam>
Component:	JavaScriptCore	Assignee:	Nobody <webkit-unassigned>
Status:	RESOLVED WONTFIX
Severity:	Normal	CC:	abarth, antonm, morrita
Priority:	P2
Version:	528+ (Nightly build)
Hardware:	PC
OS:	OS X 10.5

Hin-Chung Lam

Reported 2010-09-30 18:28:26 PDT

The failure is introduce in http://trac.webkit.org/changeset/68854

Attachments
Add attachment proposed patch, testcase, etc.

Hin-Chung Lam

Comment 1 2010-09-30 18:44:59 PDT

Expected results for fast/url/segments-from-data-url.html is: Test URL segmentation On success, you will see a series of "PASS" messages, followed by "TEST COMPLETE". PASS segments('http://user:pass@foo:21/bar;par?b#c') is '["http:","foo","21","/bar;par","?b","#c"]' FAIL segments('http:foo.com') should be ["http:","foo.com","0","/","",""]. Was ["http:","","0","foo.com","",""]. PASS segments('\t :foo.com \n') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(' foo.com ') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('a:\t foo.com') is '["a:","","0"," foo.com","",""]' FAIL segments('http://f:21/ b ? d # e ') should be ["http:","f","21","/%20b%20","?%20d%20","# e"]. Was ["http:","f","21","/ b ","?%20d%20","#%20e"]. PASS segments('http://f:/c') is '["http:","f","0","/c","",""]' PASS segments('http://f:0/c') is '["http:","f","0","/c","",""]' PASS segments('http://f:00000000000000/c') is '["http:","f","0","/c","",""]' FAIL segments('http://f:00000000000000000000080/c') should be ["http:","f","0","/c","",""]. Was ["http:","f","80","/c","",""]. PASS segments('http://f:b/c') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://f: /c') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://f:\n/c') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://f:fifty-two/c') is '[":","","0","","",""]' FAIL segments('http://f:999999/c') should be [":","","0","","",""]. Was ["http:","f","65535","/c","",""]. PASS segments('http://f: 21 / b ? d # e ') is '[":","","0","","",""]' FAIL segments('') should be ["data:","","0","text/plain,baseURL","",""]. Was [":","","0","","",""]. FAIL segments(' \t') should be ["data:","","0","text/plain,baseURL","",""]. Was [":","","0","","",""]. PASS segments(':foo.com/') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(':foo.com\\') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(':') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(':a') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(':/') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(':\\') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(':#') is '[":","","0","","",""]' FAIL segments('#') should be [":","","0","","",""]. Was ["data:","","0","text/plain,baseURL","",""]. FAIL segments('#/') should be [":","","0","","",""]. Was ["data:","","0","text/plain,baseURL","","#/"]. FAIL segments('#\\') should be [":","","0","","",""]. Was ["data:","","0","text/plain,baseURL","","#\\"]. FAIL segments('#;?') should be [":","","0","","",""]. Was ["data:","","0","text/plain,baseURL","","#;?"]. PASS segments('?') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('/') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(':23') is '[":","","0","","",""]' FAIL segments('/:23') should be ["data:","","0","/:23","",""]. Was [":","","0","","",""]. PASS segments('//') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('::') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('::23') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('foo://') is '["foo:","","0","//","",""]' PASS segments('http://a:b@c:29/d') is '["http:","c","29","/d","",""]' FAIL segments('http::@c:29') should be ["http:","c","29","/","",""]. Was ["http:","","0",":@c:29","",""]. FAIL segments('http://&a:foo(b]c@d:2/') should be ["http:","d","2","/","",""]. Was [":","","0","","",""]. FAIL segments('http://::@c@d:2') should be ["http:","d","2","/","",""]. Was [":","","0","","",""]. PASS segments('http://foo.com:b@d/') is '["http:","d","0","/","",""]' PASS segments('http://foo.com/\\@') is '["http:","foo.com","0","//@","",""]' PASS segments('http:\\\\foo.com\\') is '["http:","foo.com","0","/","",""]' PASS segments('http:\\\\a\\b:c\\d@foo.com\\') is '["http:","a","0","/b:c/d@foo.com/","",""]' PASS segments('foo:/') is '["foo:","","0","/","",""]' PASS segments('foo:/bar.com/') is '["foo:","","0","/bar.com/","",""]' PASS segments('foo://///////') is '["foo:","","0","/////////","",""]' PASS segments('foo://///////bar.com/') is '["foo:","","0","/////////bar.com/","",""]' PASS segments('foo:////://///') is '["foo:","","0","////://///","",""]' PASS segments('c:/foo') is '["c:","","0","/foo","",""]' PASS segments('//foo/bar') is '[":","","0","","",""]' FAIL segments('http://foo/path;a??e#f#g') should be ["http:","foo","0","/path;a","??e","#f#g"]. Was ["http:","foo","0","/path;a","??e","#f%23g"]. PASS segments('http://foo/abcd?efgh?ijkl') is '["http:","foo","0","/abcd","?efgh?ijkl",""]' PASS segments('http://foo/abcd#foo?bar') is '["http:","foo","0","/abcd","","#foo?bar"]' FAIL segments('[61:24:74]:98') should be ["data:","","0","text/[61:24:74]:98","",""]. Was [":","","0","","",""]. FAIL segments('http://[61:27]:98') should be [":","","0","","",""]. Was ["http:","[61:27]","98","/","",""]. FAIL segments('http:[61:27]/:foo') should be [":","","0","","",""]. Was ["http:","","0","[61:27]/:foo","",""]. PASS segments('http://[1::2]:3:4') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://2001::1') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://[2001::1') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://2001::1]') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://2001::1]:80') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://[2001::1]') is '["http:","[2001::1]","0","/","",""]' FAIL segments('http://[2001::1]:80') should be ["http:","[2001::1]","0","/","",""]. Was ["http:","[2001::1]","80","/","",""]. PASS segments('http://[[::]]') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS successfullyParsed is true TEST COMPLETE Actual result is: Test URL segmentation On success, you will see a series of "PASS" messages, followed by "TEST COMPLETE". PASS segments('http://user:pass@foo:21/bar;par?b#c') is '["http:","foo","21","/bar;par","?b","#c"]' PASS segments('http:foo.com') is '["http:","foo.com","0","/","",""]' PASS segments('\t :foo.com \n') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(' foo.com ') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('a:\t foo.com') is '["a:","","0"," foo.com","",""]' PASS segments('http://f:21/ b ? d # e ') is '["http:","f","21","/%20b%20","?%20d%20","# e"]' PASS segments('http://f:/c') is '["http:","f","0","/c","",""]' PASS segments('http://f:0/c') is '["http:","f","0","/c","",""]' PASS segments('http://f:00000000000000/c') is '["http:","f","0","/c","",""]' PASS segments('http://f:00000000000000000000080/c') is '["http:","f","0","/c","",""]' PASS segments('http://f:b/c') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://f: /c') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://f:\n/c') is '["http:","f","0","/c","",""]' PASS segments('http://f:fifty-two/c') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://f:999999/c') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://f: 21 / b ? d # e ') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('') is '["data:","","0","text/plain,baseURL","",""]' PASS segments(' \t') is '["data:","","0","text/plain,baseURL","",""]' PASS segments(':foo.com/') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(':foo.com\\') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(':') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(':a') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(':/') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(':\\') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(':#') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('#') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('#/') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('#\\') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('#;?') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('?') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('/') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments(':23') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('/:23') is '["data:","","0","/:23","",""]' PASS segments('//') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('::') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('::23') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('foo://') is '["foo:","","0","//","",""]' PASS segments('http://a:b@c:29/d') is '["http:","c","29","/d","",""]' PASS segments('http::@c:29') is '["http:","c","29","/","",""]' PASS segments('http://&a:foo(b]c@d:2/') is '["http:","d","2","/","",""]' PASS segments('http://::@c@d:2') is '["http:","d","2","/","",""]' PASS segments('http://foo.com:b@d/') is '["http:","d","0","/","",""]' PASS segments('http://foo.com/\\@') is '["http:","foo.com","0","//@","",""]' PASS segments('http:\\\\foo.com\\') is '["http:","foo.com","0","/","",""]' PASS segments('http:\\\\a\\b:c\\d@foo.com\\') is '["http:","a","0","/b:c/d@foo.com/","",""]' PASS segments('foo:/') is '["foo:","","0","/","",""]' PASS segments('foo:/bar.com/') is '["foo:","","0","/bar.com/","",""]' PASS segments('foo://///////') is '["foo:","","0","/////////","",""]' PASS segments('foo://///////bar.com/') is '["foo:","","0","/////////bar.com/","",""]' PASS segments('foo:////://///') is '["foo:","","0","////://///","",""]' PASS segments('c:/foo') is '["c:","","0","/foo","",""]' PASS segments('//foo/bar') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://foo/path;a??e#f#g') is '["http:","foo","0","/path;a","??e","#f#g"]' PASS segments('http://foo/abcd?efgh?ijkl') is '["http:","foo","0","/abcd","?efgh?ijkl",""]' PASS segments('http://foo/abcd#foo?bar') is '["http:","foo","0","/abcd","","#foo?bar"]' PASS segments('[61:24:74]:98') is '["data:","","0","text/[61:24:74]:98","",""]' PASS segments('http://[61:27]:98') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http:[61:27]/:foo') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://[1::2]:3:4') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://2001::1') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://[2001::1') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://2001::1]') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://2001::1]:80') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS segments('http://[2001::1]') is '["http:","[2001::1]","0","/","",""]' PASS segments('http://[2001::1]:80') is '["http:","[2001::1]","0","/","",""]' PASS segments('http://[[::]]') is '[":","","0","","",""]' PASS successfullyParsed is true TEST COMPLETE

Hin-Chung Lam

Comment 2 2010-09-30 18:46:49 PDT

It fails for the case of 'http://f:\n/c' The expected results of parsing is [":","","0","","",""]. The actual results is ["http:","f","0","/c","",""]. Please let me know if you are not the right person for this bug. I'll find another person. Thanks!

Adam Barth

Comment 3 2010-09-30 18:51:45 PDT

I'm the right person for this bug. It likely just needs a new baseline.

Hin-Chung Lam

Comment 4 2010-09-30 18:57:31 PDT

Please take a look at this to see if the new results is correct: http://test-results.appspot.com/dashboards/flakiness_dashboard.html#useWebKitCanary=true&tests=fast%2Furl%2Fsegments-from-data-url.html

Hajime Morrita

Comment 5 2010-09-30 19:04:51 PDT

*** Bug 46952 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

Stephen Chenney

Comment 6 2013-04-09 16:10:14 PDT

LayoutTest failures for Chromium are being marked WontFix. The Bug is still accessible and referenced from TestExpectations.

Note You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.