Bug 33565 – box-shadow seems to be 1 pixel to small

• Component: CSS
• Status: RESOLVED WONTFIX

[Mark]

Hi,

While i was trying to make something fancy with CSS3 + webkit (latest chromium nightly build) and gecko (firefox 3.6 beta 5) i noticed i had to increase my box-shadow with one pixel compared to the firefox setting of box-shadow. Both renders where based of a photoshop render.

In my case the photoshop render uses 6 px for the shadow
Firefox has the same results with 6 px
Webkit on the other hand needs 7 px for the same result.

You can find the example here: http://mageprojects.com/purecss/
Look at the shadow of the outer grey box.
The image below is the "reference" render from photoshop.
Feel free to look in the CSS and HTML code.

It's not a big deal but certainly would be nice for consistency if the Gecko and WebKit reders would match. In my examples it does because i add that 1 px.

Good luck,
Mark

[Ariya Hidayat]

The test URL http://mageprojects.com/purecss/ does not work anymore.

[Alexey Proskuryakov]

Please feel free to re-open with a new URL (or better yet, a test case attached to the bug).

[Mark]

WTF happened here!
I swear i saw this topic being closed with the exact same line and back then i also posted the NEW URL where the same test case is now shown for several months now!

So here it is AGAIN:
http://mageprojects.com/css3_tests/webkit_animation_bug/
http://mageprojects.com/css3_tests/webkit_animation_bug/
http://mageprojects.com/css3_tests/webkit_animation_bug/
http://mageprojects.com/css3_tests/webkit_animation_bug/

(just posting it a few times to make sure it gets spotted)
Real odd things are happening in this bugzilla!

Kind regards,
Mark

[Ahmad Saleem]

We don't have any test case and I tried to look on Wayback archive as well but I couldn't manage to find:

https://web.archive.org/web/20140806165842/http://mageprojects.com/css3_tests/webkit_animation_bug/

^ It shows 'server error'.

This is earliest copy of website on Wayback Archive but it shows broke image icon:

https://web.archive.org/web/20100124091911/http://mageprojects.com/purecss/

Unable to reproduce so marking this as 'RESOLVED WONTFIX' (since it was never confirmed).