51254 2010-12-17 08:08:03 -0800 <noscript> is not allowed inside <p> 2010-12-17 08:09:48 -0800 1 1 1 Unclassified WebKit DOM 528+ (Nightly build) PC OS X 10.6 RESOLVED DUPLICATE 43440 http://jsperf.com/slugs P2 Normal --- 0 mathias webkit-unassigned oldest_to_newest 323775 0 mathias 2010-12-17 08:08:03 -0800 See http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=51085: What steps will reproduce the problem? 1. Open any page with a <noscript> element inside a <p> element 2. Check the Web Inspector What is the expected result? No errors or warnings are displayed. What happens instead? The Web Inspector displays errors because, apparently, "<noscript> is not allowed inside <p>". Please provide any additional information below. Attach a screenshot if possible. Since this appears to be a WebKit bug, I filed this bug there as well: https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=43440 At first, I wasn't sure what to do with this, so I asked #whatwg: http://krijnhoetmer.nl/irc-logs/whatwg/20100803#l-952 # [21:20] <Matjas> What is up with this? Web Inspector gives the following error: "<noscript> is not allowed inside <p>" Screenshot: http://i.imgur.com/rQSRl.png # [21:21] <Matjas> But the HTML validates and everything… Is this is a Webkit bug or am I doing something wrong? # [21:21] <annevk5> sounds like a WebKit bug # [21:23] <Matjas> annevk5: http://www.w3.org/TR/REC-html40/interact/scripts.html#h-18.3.1 says "<!ELEMENT NOSCRIPT - - (%block;)+ " # [21:23] <Matjas> (That's from HTML4 though) # [21:24] <annevk5> HTML4 does not seem relevant # [21:24] <annevk5> and that does not tell anything about what <p> allows # [21:24] <annevk5> though I guess if <noscript> just allows %block; <p> does not allow <noscript> # [21:24] <annevk5> but still a bug in WebKit 323776 1 76881 mathias 2010-12-17 08:08:56 -0800 Created attachment 76881 Screenshot of the error in Web Inspector 323778 2 mathias 2010-12-17 08:09:48 -0800 *** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of bug 43440 *** 76881 2010-12-17 08:08:56 -0800 2010-12-17 08:08:56 -0800 Screenshot of the error in Web Inspector noscript-p.png image/png 2652 mathias iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAZEAAAAgCAIAAABcotJkAAAKI0lEQVR42u1cwcskRxXvv2gOmoN4 +dIIMdkk2+iuu8IOJB5sWELMqKw6RD3MQRgQYfDSIGZOc5qgfIk4iTJB55Ih0mh6d21YxuxkoYM2 cZBS6UPDPquKborZ3z7GStFfJkP96EN3fVX1Xv3q1evq/qZ/AXl4eHh8duBzloeHh89ZHh4eHj5n 8agoGdO2OgVD7h6OYxoMaLJgCjvAKqHzTYfUYXO0fswoczqf03JNZeXXkWssYc56+PDh35dvZ995 6fZ3X7pz6+Xb374pL2UhHTUEhQGl4nC1XkDrXWeG3OHuZ01ZSpOIgglT2AHGPRqtO6QOm6P1o0U6 pSCgKFb+B2PHYHBs3n14dx9LmLP++d67f/3G14ubLxbf+mbxSixP7r54/eP33v2kiVtQTXuoKxIV 4Uqrar45lleEQAjxSDM1f5kgZ6Dz7oTwftpbzyeQnqAQrR82VBEORyKJaJw6RYg9n2gd/URYho07 SpWw4nlzleXAPEcIBgOy5NKcB0ZI7bC0YcE6xRLmrI9+v/jLV576+Kc/+cfPf1bEfXnIE3kpCz9a vnVopks6TyjQebrKKYxo0FeXQUR5S9lKVVBHOCJBjxYGPdpU7aC2FPea8tGiHVWmuh3FTXmuK+cz 6oUU9o0VZT2kfqir9anQ1GbTplWvp2ZxmpHERFYbUbalg0BDvPMIC0LQTxYVDcOmcjSiHRlkkJ6g EKxrenv9vX5mMU1S3XbeDrNvnh3OR21hIKtZUYeEsHxic946+mkRtBA2ECH22Gp/dFc88wwhTDDg MG2bI3iSh6aHeW4RycyCdY0lzFnv3PjqNnrywY9/8J/7H9z/0fflIU/kpSxc9q+wKydb0SDU7sZ0 vqZKlqXa9opoR3HQbPZ2K1W43FJd0iCg/pwUhCpc6JjYZO0Df61a9ROVtncbmq9Ioe02ntFOULam omqz+1aH3W6v2ngpz1TMhcleNemAEM2dvMxoMmxWSHJOpSAGaIh3HmFDCPrJoqJVSqJWJ6OAoplV zkLrzXPEqlQnxU7NQhTQfNvUXOlhzmMKRiRRnGsqShI5G2c8dUgIxyc2Z62jnwg+aDFsrCMEkSUU hGYNM8wzhDDBAMO0ao7gSV4AyVZLm3DBusYS5qy3X7j+t2uX7l36Yj64+d8Pt/KQJ/Jyc+3S7164 To/FRO+GBjMSjyzRXnPHXo2ax/h0QsGwTeoJBQOqdfT0dcJOZpQVpnmTlSWgW8E8tEuu0fpm1gSN qSYIkevpCZi/MobAeYA9Iegnj5pWM4pCdSsLA4qSvfTUM+kJC1nrk1DtzFdDNSixafYIqqbsP1KG ol4zBenYZMBEt0Lw1CEhyCffnLH+OD9tgxbDBiPEIWdxzDOEQDAww7RozuAQyeOeJNk2knHBusYS 5qw3bly597Vnbj/9hbsyZz14IA95Ii9l4Zs3mH1WuaFkpKczVDeiQrS+hiT2bu/8Eq1ovaRE381m uaaOz1lB6JqzMrF3b8mWzUY3GtAypdpmUtF5BlaEoJ+Idmg99dhSVTTrm3zUmBiRARRy1rOEekMa RMrbyUhWaGN3pPe8O9oJZY4cchZPCPJpkbMYP62CFsOGjxBZnlKaHwiYXD+dlQdzFkMIBAMzzIPN nXPWROUsq0jGBWsdS0gy5qz51Wfz58/yH37v3x9u//xyLA95Ii9l4evXLh+45+crGkbN3vKxAyv1 nWqtHz1GvfZZpqI0azZccdC6W1Gkb4OVPC1pmWGgG9Q11aV+qCnkudmmJbqrabOYzW18vKK6amqO daafLtjHOt4Q4zwDC0LATwa6n6EO962iK0zIxN5a9ZyVJCqmkLFeZbJQubeZq5PhwjwjrAvdyZZW mdnP54LqLYXcfp6nDgnh+cTmaJ3z0yJoIWyYCDFkwlYOsVNu96dU1cqlxZphHglhgxaHadccwZPc GBKZeWSziGRYsLaxhCRjztr89s3F2efu3Xrlzqu3/vSlJ+Rx+9Vb8nJx9vkP3vrN//1vIBhYL4E3 be07ThJqvZnCqnU3o7At73MUmObmyISqZkrCvVfj66l5z2fxHyLGEOM8wIYQ9JNDvSFDkQyUZP+H NnEzfMEU8tOhjRaqfFnAq/GA4nY6prEpTFIr6hhCgE+mOVrn/LQJWgwbPkKqrHFSEAs+kpF5JIQL BhymRXObOcJX41aRjAvWLpZ4kgPax/3VO288+UT23Nn7V555/+rTt587k5f3//gHcoaJj93ucYWC AKqmqMgSmqmIKt28pi6AzrsSYgGgqKKLsF5X2tY+oWJHor54PtE6+nkEYQOR7D7vOMxOUdd777M+ 5Vjif1N651fzX15+6rWrz7925dlfXP7y3V+/LgvpyIH7dkEeHj5sHCAUIb2IQr3xLGr/7U53qGiz JQ8PHzaOECXlGaUZVf57Qw8PD49PhOBfHh4eHp8d+H2Wh4eH16Lx8PDwONKcVRWUbZpzUVBe0EWi 3tJwQpWLRo89hBzylgBevetY4T7v+Lli1h4pFcLPewfoTj8rHZv/EKfq+6ML1ZASa/iZLAt3xSXz /Xa8OE2ZsO7RifPdzzv+oBR+A/mpzTvipCPEXT8rS5iPBhiRHVExejr1AQ0p6NP80LY2hZ3rPZVL UBc5AZkwO20mi7EDnOWi3LWZ3AHR3oHalDV1aB1xmOSaGdHRwF0/C3MWK7Izb7V4BgOtATKhGkWg WA0pFNUynxbuG3LX6EFxJVM46lF8ThonJhNmoc3EOM8rQ8XNeT6leO4oF9WNNpM9UshZHahNWUiP gXUETzIuQ77P7tGtfhbmLFZkZxLSaEXrMQUDKrOmFYhAcbo/KKrFGXLW6EFxpb2fSpuMc1oyYXba TOg8rwyl59qsc0e5qA60mZz2Wd2pTVlIj6F1Bkgyq8WGfR4D3PWzMGexIjuTkCY5bWf6u8pa3SsE IwIFuj+cqBYactLo4cWVTMNoenoyYbbaTOC8rcqKo1xUB9pMDjmrA7Upe+kxtM4CSWaWIfZ5FHDX z8qS5stSozjOhKnSk8skE1rlo9I5ixGBAt0fVlQLDbnrPaG4knnzalw6LZkwe20mYZezmgg5j/UU O8pFdafN5J6z3NWmrKXHOOsIlmRchtgnT133cNfPQsXrddFI5/SSAzmr3stZKALF6f6gqBZryF3v CcWViNq5NDgxmTArbSZ0nh/7tpW1KZVjYeIoF9WBNpMtapUWFyOVIsuSdlUHalOW0mNonQeSjMsQ +mSpu3i462fVNB207zgj2ghWZCeJaKJzVmhyFohAMbo/jBQRGnLUe+L/O7OhQGulG5yaTJiFNpOV MhTVNOm31dTDtaNcVAfaTJbQzJtjvCaiDtSmrKTH0DoPJBmXId8nUtc93PSz+Bd7ojsRKJQiumi9 p8WQgtGJy4Tx1LkrQ0GHDi65z/vxq025W3dfhtjnhcJdP8vD6z15HKvaFFr3+lkeXu/J4zjVptC6 18/y8PDwOBr8D5o8bSp/uEunAAAAAElFTkSuQmCC