223223 2021-03-15 17:10:08 -0700 [ macOS Debug ARM64 ] 2X w3c/svg tests are constantly text failing 2024-04-11 02:54:05 -0700 1 1 1 Unclassified WebKit SVG WebKit Nightly Build Unspecified Unspecified NEW InRadar P2 Normal --- 1 jenner webkit-unassigned ap cdumez graouts sabouhallawa webkit-bot-watchers-bugzilla webkit-bug-importer ysuzuki zimmermann oldest_to_newest 1739739 0 jenner 2021-03-15 17:10:08 -0700 imported/w3c/web-platform-tests/svg/import/paths-data-03-f-manual.svg svg/W3C-SVG-1.1/paths-data-03-f.svg Are constantly text failing in macOS Debug on Apple Silicon only. HISTORY URL: https://results.webkit.org/?suite=layout-tests&suite=layout-tests&test=svg%2FW3C-SVG-1.1%2Fpaths-data-03-f.svg&test=imported%2Fw3c%2Fweb-platform-tests%2Fsvg%2Fimport%2Fpaths-data-03-f-manual.svg While only one test notes that it is imported, both tests appear to be imported tests from MIT. Here is the text diff for the first test. The diff for the second test is very very similar. I have also attached both diff files to the bug: --- /Volumes/Data/worker/bigsur-debug-applesilicon-tests-wk1/build/layout-test-results/svg/W3C-SVG-1.1/paths-data-03-f-expected.txt +++ /Volumes/Data/worker/bigsur-debug-applesilicon-tests-wk1/build/layout-test-results/svg/W3C-SVG-1.1/paths-data-03-f-actual.txt @@ -24,7 +24,7 @@ chunk 1 text run 1 at (390.00,300.00) startOffset 0 endOffset 4 width 23.34: "M, a" RenderSVGRect {rect} at (348,243) size 4x4 [fill={[type=SOLID] [color=#0000FF]}] [x=348.00] [y=243.00] [width=4.00] [height=4.00] RenderSVGRect {rect} at (428,303) size 4x4 [fill={[type=SOLID] [color=#0000FF]}] [x=428.00] [y=303.00] [width=4.00] [height=4.00] - RenderSVGPath {path} at (257,29) size 201x100 [fill={[type=SOLID] [color=#C0C000] [fill rule=EVEN-ODD]}] [data="M 270 30 C 252.272 50.1015 253.547 80.6061 272.891 99.158 C 292.234 117.71 322.766 117.71 342.109 99.158 C 361.453 80.6061 362.728 50.1015 345 30 C 325.402 41.3151 315.847 64.383 321.704 86.2422 C 327.561 108.101 347.37 123.301 370 123.301 C 392.63 123.301 412.439 108.101 418.296 86.2422 C 424.153 64.383 414.598 41.3151 395 30 C 370.621 36.2946 354.726 59.7348 357.898 84.7125 C 361.071 109.69 382.322 128.412 407.5 128.412 C 432.678 128.412 453.929 109.69 457.101 84.7125 C 460.274 59.7348 444.379 36.2946 420 30 Z"] + RenderSVGPath {path} at (257,29) size 201x100 [fill={[type=SOLID] [color=#C0C000] [fill rule=EVEN-ODD]}] [data="M 270 30 C 252.272 50.1015 253.547 80.6061 272.891 99.158 C 292.234 117.71 322.766 117.71 342.109 99.158 C 361.453 80.6061 362.728 50.1015 345 30 C 325.402 41.3151 315.847 64.383 321.704 86.2422 C 327.561 108.101 347.37 123.301 370 123.301 C 392.63 123.301 412.439 108.101 418.296 86.2422 C 424.153 64.383 414.598 41.3151 395 30 C 370.621 36.2946 354.726 59.7348 357.898 84.7125 C 361.071 109.69 382.322 128.412 407.5 128.412 C 432.678 128.412 453.929 109.69 457.102 84.7125 C 460.274 59.7348 444.379 36.2946 420 30 Z"] RenderSVGText {text} at (280,124) size 65x14 contains 1 chunk(s) RenderSVGInlineText {#text} at (0,0) size 65x14 chunk 1 text run 1 at (280.00,135.00) startOffset 0 endOffset 13 width 64.02: "M, A, a, a, z" 1739741 1 423265 jenner 2021-03-15 17:11:21 -0700 Created attachment 423265 diffs from text failing tests Attaching two diffs from text failing tests. 1739744 2 webkit-bug-importer 2021-03-15 17:11:59 -0700 <rdar://problem/75455148> 1739746 3 jenner 2021-03-15 17:12:55 -0700 These tests only fail on Apple Silicon Macs, and as such I cannot reproduce the failures because I do not have access to an AS Mac. 1739759 4 jenner 2021-03-15 17:27:06 -0700 Updated test expectations to [ Failure ] while test is being looked at. https://trac.webkit.org/changeset/274454/webkit 1740810 5 ap 2021-03-17 11:24:52 -0700 Looks like a rounding issue, but a pretty large one: 457.102 vs. 457.101. 2027742 6 graouts 2024-04-11 02:54:05 -0700 imported/w3c/web-platform-tests/svg/import/paths-data-03-f-manual.svg is no longer a failure, removed the expectation in 277362@main. 423265 2021-03-15 17:11:21 -0700 2021-03-15 17:11:21 -0700 diffs from text failing tests 223223- Text Diffs.zip application/zip 3624 jenner UEsDBBQAAAAAAE2Jb1IAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATACAAMjIzMjIzLSBUZXh0IERpZmZzL1VUDQAHcvdP YHL3T2B8909gdXgLAAEE9QEAAAQUAAAAUEsDBBQACAAIAOWGb1IAAAAAAAAAALUIAAAyACAAMjIz MjIzLSBUZXh0IERpZmZzL3BhdGhzLWRhdGEtMDMtZi1tYW51YWwtZGlmZi50eHRVVA0AB97zT2Bz 909gcvdPYHV4CwABBPUBAAAEFAAAAO2V32/TMBDH3/dXnLqXTa0d/zjHNlKlIQYICRja0B6Y9pC1 7hota6vEoR3T/ncuSZsiHhhCPPBAFCU+5/z153ynHGMMkstlUd+HKjnNYpasl+VdKJOb/LaqSzYN N/Uty1arIlR5kU+WCxZDFSu2vpPJTZ0X06TIHpZ1bKdZGaq6iFWS36+WZQzTZK0nyTrcsFWRxdmy vO9WJ9XX261PssrivGJT2poJzWbsPlvUWcHCZhUmpMDjJh4Mh8N/kzKbRHq1jCcnwJQZWRi2z5OT A9hfk3m9uAMJMWwilPWChlmEI+0FF2KkRfM6hipmZTybzaoQQUBYTLdjhHU+jXNQmmt8AYMPI8gG O/lz8gvlxeXbczoveCzp+dSKGydGKAzJ5t8C2I2Fq1leFOPHq/iwCuOLs/fvTq/harIsluX4UND1 5s31E81sxhodAdHwYaxQd8MWYYydMQ/57Tx21rMgVuqR+TMQVD2IFs+CsJ9APlHS4LFJXQeCyo/Q bzm0xo1M02dYUvuq2abxobwVYfz68vVHdnZ62gI29TAefABlBWgBr0AZxZVVYASXQhqyNTdowQme ilSSo+LOS/CeS+OaBZ4WaAQpLbcStFLcEtTOREU6fu+uU8nR6F5Pp+SvXL+fRtOBaGU4CgUouZaG HKXhjkBS5Npp+iy5FQgu5QqVahdYbkhRCtdIkZLl2oJsaq4xKcLdmJyJOtX9BErFUft+LUrHlU9/ UEeFFIHebY8SufFuT+d32JYCU01cJIApaIMUXwrGc0tFSbal83PgaFoqsz0RYRtuz1MP2ilOh0ho jhMWoKCweotANJFbt/9OCfLK75Yj6TcR7PUxFZRR7AkQKQTre0JUbeq/DK4Phv/L73/5/YXyU39W fj//hj83veax6Thd+SnqB3Rk2/pLzYYSRp0yZvmion7Utqij6njftnqld4siX4RO73AvKEbiBzH8 jX5HCE2/k9r8st9JvW14lC+huob3knpee38bHHwHUEsHCAbBcR/tAgAAtQgAAFBLAwQUAAgACADl hm9SAAAAAAAAAAAUAwAAPQAgAF9fTUFDT1NYLzIyMzIyMy0gVGV4dCBEaWZmcy8uX3BhdGhzLWRh dGEtMDMtZi1tYW51YWwtZGlmZi50eHRVVA0AB97zT2Bz909gf/dPYHV4CwABBPUBAAAEFAAAALVQ O28TQRCes0EkoSCIBNEgubFEir293J2dh2nuYQuEAhK2FLqwvts7r7L38N5ezL+gSpMukagoEKKj paanoUEU/AgK9uyLAEtIaRhpZnZnvm8088H1uzegAXBAgtazYetFq7aqBqvKTYDGN5XVv7kBVzJn NHq+eFUM7Z7yn0uQa4s6PAK4FWSJTvKcUz0hAZ+3tZcqdAC2/uhRSUIiyf7xgf9Y0sTPZinPSEhD n0hacU6VewDtf3MOJ1TQgciSojroiwoPATZ/46clESSVLKXQhPYP7/YUP/149rX//e1r9v5qty/b OOeskIZxrlnOJ9h8551+XllbtDStxjSWOHcuSRda42j9zUTKvNjHeFwyHuozOj5mUs9EjAUtSi4L 7FTLI5fFw1Ign47LGM1LQ8ZZkKXo8Mk2GtFCIYW5Y9u20TaNB6ZtbmGW5JmQNMQzK8BqMso5kVEm EiTn+OIkrjE4J3JSoEpNZFgoQglJS8JRyKJIl6/k0Xr8H/esJ+gTmXBYgZvwoVbuUsLm3wpq96fY MHatXtewo8gKaW9IIiJYz3C9vrPneWh70O0gu+v7yO16fbRn77im5biDfmcXfgFQSwcIriY2j8AB AAAUAwAAUEsDBBQACAAIAOOGb1IAAAAAAAAAAHEIAAArACAAMjIzMjIzLSBUZXh0IERpZmZzL3Bh dGhzLWRhdGEtMDMtZi1kaWZmLnR4dFVUDQAH2vNPYHP3T2By909gdXgLAAEE9QEAAAQUAAAA7ZVR a9tIEMff8ykG56XF3tXu7Kx298CQI2mPwvVSmpJCQx4UexOL6GwjrRqnod+9I9mWSx/aUg7upcLI O6uZv36zM2iEEJBdrqr239hkZ0UqsodVfR/r7Ka8a9pazONNeyeK9bqKTVmVs9VSpNikRjzc6+ym Lat5VhWPqzb126KOTVulJms+3mXvzam4uPxLaKmzdZEWjZizvlBG3Iq4WcdZinOZNuloPB7/HwzF LLVF1ROcnIBAmjgY9/eTkyM4XLNFu7wHDSluEtTtkpdFgmcmKKnUxKju7zk0qajT+e1tExMoiMv5 bk3wUM7TAtBIQ3/A6PUEitFe/i37xZoB3/JpwFPN989bcfITJMOy5acItCG4ui2ravp0lR7XcXpx /vers2u4mq2qVT09Vny9fHn9mXc2Uw5lIF4+Tllhu+wRprQ1FrG8W6St9UMQQs8p/hIIh+5BWOFH IOIbkDdcLXjqarYFQesmGHYcqPRGK/VdllN1qvrXdD5ctypOX1y++Eecn531gF0jTEevAZ0Co+AU 0KJEh2CV1Epbto205MArmatcsyNKHzSEILX1XUDgAEOgtZNOg0GULs8Hk5B1wsHd5FqSNYOeydkf /fA+Q3YLYtBKUgikpdGWHbWVnkFyksYbfqylUwQ+l0iIfYCTlhW18p0UKzlpHOiu5zqTM9yv2Zmp czNskEZJJgyxpL3EkH+lTkicgdm/njRJG/yBLuyxHSeGXV4sQDkYS5xfDjZIx03JtuPz8+B5W6Pd nYhyHXeQeQDjUfIhMpqXjAWkOK3BYhDD5M4fnnOBAoZ9OLF+l8FBn3LFFaWBgIhTcGEgJOxL/2F0 fTT+3X6/2+8/aD/8tfb79jP8rps1T93E2bWfVxONtOu/3G40Ac/BVJTLhudRP6KeNc8PY2tQerWs ymXc6h0fBNVEfS32E/OOEbp5p4397rzTZjfwuF4KtwPvT555/e/T6OgLUEsHCF9I/zHZAgAAcQgA AFBLAwQUAAgACADjhm9SAAAAAAAAAAAnAwAANgAgAF9fTUFDT1NYLzIyMzIyMy0gVGV4dCBEaWZm cy8uX3BhdGhzLWRhdGEtMDMtZi1kaWZmLnR4dFVUDQAH2vNPYHP3T2B/909gdXgLAAEE9QEAAAQU AAAAtVAxb9NAFH5OVFHoQBAqAwMKQhF0OPtiOyRtGLDjBBAqrXBE2NpLfHZOPceO70zZ+QGIDbHB ihhYWZn5CTAhAWJGDCycm6AiS0hdeNJ77+6973t674OVC6egArBNJvUdv/6wvrSiBqeVmwCVHyqr f/UqnMic4fD+4lUwtJvKv5QgK4s61AAuTpJYJ2nKqc6JkLmgQUAkvbLrL6Dargq3Ac4e42Iy4Yve cxVaABt/9agkik+2Dra9O5LGXnI44wkJaOCpqQXng/JLAI1/c0ZTmtFBlsSiOPy7CjcA1o/x85xk ZCbZjMLlnzv7xSafoNM9uhgaX3vn5sa9dy8+9j+/fsrenkyzso1TzoTE+KVmOe9h/U117dvqmaUg 2hJTKXHO/yG90ip7tSdTKVOxZRjjnPFAP6TjAyb1JIuMjIqcS2E4xTHIZZGfZ8ij4zxCRyWfcTZJ Zmh0t4mGVChkZrZt28YNE18zbXPDEI8iY2T1kP/gFmrqTSMlcipQISHCFgpRwMJQl4/lXi36j1ss J+hTGfPVtWcldaoldX7NDYw7Vvc6tsPQCkjXJyHJWLfVHvRbA7eF+tjCyO44Htrsb1qoZ7pNx/Us 02y78BtQSwcIKMpyTcoBAAAnAwAAUEsBAhQDFAAAAAAATYlvUgAAAAAAAAAAAAAAABMAIAAAAAAA AAAAAO1BAAAAADIyMzIyMy0gVGV4dCBEaWZmcy9VVA0AB3L3T2By909gfPdPYHV4CwABBPUBAAAE FAAAAFBLAQIUAxQACAAIAOWGb1IGwXEf7QIAALUIAAAyACAAAAAAAAAAAACkgVEAAAAyMjMyMjMt IFRleHQgRGlmZnMvcGF0aHMtZGF0YS0wMy1mLW1hbnVhbC1kaWZmLnR4dFVUDQAH3vNPYHP3T2By 909gdXgLAAEE9QEAAAQUAAAAUEsBAhQDFAAIAAgA5YZvUq4mNo/AAQAAFAMAAD0AIAAAAAAAAAAA AKSBvgMAAF9fTUFDT1NYLzIyMzIyMy0gVGV4dCBEaWZmcy8uX3BhdGhzLWRhdGEtMDMtZi1tYW51 YWwtZGlmZi50eHRVVA0AB97zT2Bz909gf/dPYHV4CwABBPUBAAAEFAAAAFBLAQIUAxQACAAIAOOG b1JfSP8x2QIAAHEIAAArACAAAAAAAAAAAACkgQkGAAAyMjMyMjMtIFRleHQgRGlmZnMvcGF0aHMt ZGF0YS0wMy1mLWRpZmYudHh0VVQNAAfa809gc/dPYHL3T2B1eAsAAQT1AQAABBQAAABQSwECFAMU AAgACADjhm9SKMpyTcoBAAAnAwAANgAgAAAAAAAAAAAApIFbCQAAX19NQUNPU1gvMjIzMjIzLSBU ZXh0IERpZmZzLy5fcGF0aHMtZGF0YS0wMy1mLWRpZmYudHh0VVQNAAfa809gc/dPYH/3T2B1eAsA AQT1AQAABBQAAABQSwUGAAAAAAUABQBpAgAAqQsAAAAA